HI Everyone,
I strongly agree that if everyone votes there will be bias, due to the mentioned reasons that not everyone is going to vote, and also there is a greater liklihood of personal preferance.
I do imagine that the 3 Judges, atleast the 2 we know of, not only by character but also by position here are more likley than not to take the responsibility and motive and concern to seek to judge fairly based on criteria and not personal preferance. I just believe that. When a person is in a position such as this, not always, but often, they take the responsbility seriously, and fairness is a key responsbility.
Yes Bogden could do the final judging, but, is that what he wants; does he have time; would he rather the community be mature enough to do some of the work rather than assign it all to him? We are not children.
I think I do agree that it should not be publicized which ones are leading the race during voting...bias again.
I really am not comfortable with nominations being public either. Obviously people can be hurt or offended here by seeing themselves "not" included in certain people's nominations.
Thanks, Kim S
|