Perfect and Immortal Joined: 06 Jun 2005 Total Posts: 394

Re: BFA Results: July, 2007 Posted: 08-20-2007 01:57 AM winner can win only once,not twice like J Sanchez. So other members can win too. http://kingdomgrant.org/perfect for Christ http://lifeinst.com [please use 15614 as u referral,ty]

Perfect and Immortal, I completely agree with you. Each person should only be allowed to win once per year, as to make it fair and give others a chance.

BUT, As it is, the same 3-4 people are going to win continually through out the year.

And NOT because their forum is the BEST, but because of WHO they are...

The judges eyes get blurry when judging their friends forums..

This is why I will not allow my forum to be in the nominations at this forum again.

I am just glad to see that others out there realize that this forum needs improved Rules and Fairness..

~Monica

Hi Monica,

Good for you girl, tell them how it is as there are just too many arse lickers about!

Best Wishes

John.

After reading the Rules:

I still feel the same, as Georgios, Monica & John P.

I mean, if a person truly reads these rules, there is definetly, somebody somewhere (judge/judges's), who is very very prejudice to certain people

I would say BFA needs some new judges, maybe, new judges nominated each and every month.

But, who am I to say how you run your/Adland/whoever's forum it is.  By the way, who's forum is it?

Bj

Hello Everybody,

I just need to address some of the comments in this thread.

Regarding the same person having option to win more than once.
The gaol of the BFA is to motivate our members to produce quality, original and interesting forums.

If one person spends lots of time on community and produces several forums in different topic, why should this person be not allowed to participate every month. The good forum is good one no matter if this comes from the same person or not.

In fact in live certain people always produce best pieces in certain areas. Should they be denied recognition because other people need to be recognized.
Look at sport. Is the fastest runner denied to run again because he/she won last time?

Is the person denied to participate in several sports at the same time?

Regarding judging.

Every month we had one new judge added to the team and one replaced. This month we had two new judges replaced. In addition we have added additional criteria which is most voted forum.

This new criteria has 15% influence on the final mark so the voting can help now as much as 15%.

If your forum was voted as top 5 last month, you need to re-apply next month because the ones which were ahead of you, are becoming winners as we go.
Also judges are changing, thus they might have different look at the forum. Also your forum might improve.

If your forum wasn't in the top 5, you need to start working on it, if you care about being voted as top forum of the month.
Complaining at judges doesn't get anybody anywhere, at least in my world.
Nobody gets paid for it. Even their names are not mentioned.

Bogdan